Posted on: April 23, 2024 Posted by: H.R. Zimmerer Comments: 0

Anne Brontë makes a governess’s daily work compelling by showing how responsibility becomes impossible when every useful form of authority is withheld.

A review of Agnes Grey by Anne Brontë

By H.R. Zimmerer

Spoiler warning: This review discusses the complete novel, including its ending.

Content note: Cruelty to animals and mistreatment of a governess.

IN THIS REVIEW
A worn school desk holds a single small flower beside a rain-streaked window.

THE BOOK

Agnes Grey by Anne Brontë, Penguin Classics book cover.

Agnes Grey
Anne Brontë

First publication
1847

Form · Novel

Edition & cover details
Read the primary text free
Find an edition

Agnes Grey is expected to educate children whose parents will not permit her to govern them. When they disobey, she is inadequate. When she attempts discipline, she is objectionable. The arrangement is remarkably efficient at ensuring that every failure belongs to the employee.

Anne Brontë’s first novel finds its force in that ordinary unfairness. Its scale is modest beside the Gothic violence of Wuthering Heights, but I would not mistake a quieter manner for a smaller intelligence.

Agnes begins work partly because her family needs money and partly because she wants to discover what she can do. Her wish to be useful contains youthful confidence. The world answers by giving her duties while repeatedly declining to recognise her as a person.

An employee inside the family

The governess occupies an awkward place in the household. Agnes is educated enough to teach the children, yet her employment prevents the comfortable equality that education might otherwise suggest. She witnesses family life without possessing the protections of belonging to it.

The Bloomfields make this position almost absurdly untenable. Their confidence in their children survives conduct that would trouble anyone permitted to judge it honestly. Agnes is hired to improve behaviour the parents keep rewarding.

The episode involving Tom Bloomfield’s cruelty to nestling birds is one of the novel’s most distressing moments. Agnes acts to prevent the prolonged suffering he intends. The adults’ indulgence of him exposes the moral education taking place beneath the formal lessons.

Anne’s attention is unusually exact here. Cruelty is being cultivated through amusement, approval and the refusal to disappoint a child. Agnes cannot correct it simply by explaining that it is wrong when the household’s more powerful members keep making it pleasurable.

What a young woman is taught to want

The Murrays offer a different set of difficulties. Agnes’s older pupils have more polished manners, but polish does little to improve their treatment of her. Rosalie’s beauty and social opportunities encourage her to understand other people’s feelings as material for entertainment.

Her conduct toward Mr Weston matters because Agnes has begun to value him. Rosalie can flirt and withdraw with a freedom that her governess does not possess. Agnes must watch without being able to state plainly what the performance costs her.

I find Rosalie most interesting after she obtains the advantageous marriage she has pursued. Becoming Lady Ashby gives her position without supplying the happiness she expected. Her later dissatisfaction does not make her earlier behaviour harmless, but it gives the portrait more weight than a simple punishment for vanity.

Anne is also attentive to the limited possibilities presented to these young women. Their training in accomplishment and appearance has practical aims. A marriage can be a triumph in the language of the household and still produce a life its occupants find miserable.

Agnes’s own judgement is morally assured, sometimes so assured that the novel can feel narrow in its distribution of sympathy. Her narration rarely offers the ambiguity I find in Lucy Snowe. I do not always need that ambiguity here, though I occasionally want the people she condemns to possess more life beyond their faults.

Kindness with something to do

Mr Weston earns Agnes’s regard through acts that would matter even if no romance followed. His attention to Nancy Brown gives kindness a practical object. He notices need without converting the person in need into an opportunity to display himself.

That is an appealing basis for affection. Agnes has spent much of the book surrounded by people whose behaviour changes according to the importance of their audience. Weston’s conduct offers evidence she can trust before she knows whether he returns her feelings.

The school Agnes establishes with her mother gives the ending another source of satisfaction. Work remains part of her future. The novel allows the women to respond to loss by making an undertaking together, drawing on abilities other households have undervalued.

The final romantic resolution is gentle and swift. Readers seeking dramatic reversals may find it too easily arranged after the patient account of employment. For me, the greater limitation is that we spend relatively little time inside the steadier life Agnes has helped create.

Still, the book has earned the significance of being treated with consideration. Anne has shown what the absence of it looks like at breakfast, in a lesson, during a visit and at the end of a working day. When Agnes is finally wanted for her own company, I understand exactly why that matters.

Primary text: Agnes Grey · Cover shown: ISBN 9780140432107

READ NEXT

Leave a Comment