Helen’s departure is the centre of Anne Brontë’s novel, but her paintings, her work and the story she chooses to tell make the life beyond that departure equally important.
A review of The Tenant of Wildfell Hall by Anne Brontë
By H.R. Zimmerer
Spoiler warning: This review discusses the complete novel, including its ending.
Content note: Domestic abuse, alcohol misuse and manipulation of a child.
IN THIS REVIEW

THE BOOK

The Tenant of Wildfell Hall
Anne Brontë
First publication
1848
Form · Novel
Edition & cover details
Read the primary text free
Find an edition
The neighbours want an explanation for Helen Graham before they have offered her much kindness. A young woman arrives at Wildfell Hall with a child, earns money by painting, and keeps parts of her life private. In a small community, those facts become an invitation to supply the rest.
The Tenant of Wildfell Hall begins with that appetite for an account of somebody else’s conduct. Anne Brontë then makes the act of obtaining an account one of the book’s most searching moral questions.
I find Helen’s independence compelling partly because the novel gives it practical demands. She needs somewhere to live. She needs work she can sell. She needs to protect her son while managing the danger created by other people’s curiosity.
The marriage inside the diary
Helen’s diary overturns the incomplete story Gilbert Markham has been telling himself. We encounter a younger woman who believes her judgement is sufficiently strong to recognise a good man beneath Arthur Huntingdon’s faults. She imagines that marriage will give her affection the opportunity to improve him.
Anne lets the confidence of that hope become painful without inviting us to despise the woman who possesses it. Arthur can be attractive and amusing. His capacity to please is part of the problem: charm gives Helen reasons to doubt the evidence she dislikes.
The deterioration of the marriage is cumulative. Alcohol, humiliation and infidelity enter a household in which Helen’s objections are treated as further defects in her character. His companions help make cruelty sociable. What she experiences as degradation can be retold among friends as a wife’s inability to enjoy herself.
Arthur’s conduct toward their child makes her position intolerable. He begins teaching little Arthur to share his habits and mock his mother. Remaining becomes a decision with consequences for somebody who cannot decide for himself.
The book understands how protection can demand disobedience. Helen’s preparations are obstructed; money and her painting materials become means through which Arthur can constrain her. Her work therefore carries more than symbolic independence. It is part of the machinery of getting away.
Gilbert must learn to listen
The diary’s position within Gilbert’s narrative prevents him from becoming an uncomplicated rescuer. Before he knows Helen’s history, he permits jealousy and rumour to govern his behaviour. His violent attack on Frederick Lawrence is a particularly ugly demonstration of how easily desire can appoint itself judge.
Gilbert’s later affection does not make that incident disappear. I appreciate the disturbance it creates around a familiar romantic pattern: a man who wishes to be preferred can still behave as though a woman’s privacy is an offence against him.
Helen must become legible to him before he can understand his mistake. That arrangement has its own limitation, since her story reaches us inside the account he eventually sends to his friend. Yet the long interruption by her diary forces his assumptions to give way to sustained attention.
Anne’s religious conviction also deserves to be taken seriously within the novel. Helen’s faith informs her conduct and her hope for moral change. The tragedy lies partly in the use of that hope to sustain expectations Arthur repeatedly refuses to meet.
At times the argument becomes explicit enough to narrow the fiction. The diary can feel determined to close every possible route by which Arthur might excuse himself. I find the book strongest when an ordinary domestic exchange has already made the judgement unavoidable.
A future she can enter freely
Helen’s return to nurse the dying Arthur complicates any easy account of departure as the end of obligation. It is a choice she makes under changed circumstances, with conditions concerning her son. The narrative does not use it to establish that the escape was a mistake.
Nor does Arthur’s decline provide a satisfying transformation. Anne refuses to make Helen’s earlier faith in his reform correct after all. His deterioration leaves the difficulty of her decisions intact.
The final movement gives Helen property and security that alter the terms of a possible marriage to Gilbert. Her offer of the winter rose is memorable because she participates in deciding what happens next. She is no longer simply the object of his uncertainty or generosity.
I wish Gilbert’s development were tested as fully as Helen’s. The novel has made us alert to men whose emotion exceeds their judgement, and his account cannot quite remove every doubt it has earned.
Even so, the book’s achievement is formidable. Helen has a history before the romance, a trade beyond it, and a child whose welfare cannot be subordinated to its completion. The happy ending has to make room for the life she has already fought to preserve.
Primary text: The Tenant of Wildfell Hall · Cover shown: ISBN 9780140434743
