Posted on: February 15, 2024 Posted by: H.R. Zimmerer Comments: 0

Emily Brontë’s novel gives its famous passion a long aftermath. The younger people have to grow up in the houses Catherine and Heathcliff leave behind.

A review of Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë

By H.R. Zimmerer

Spoiler warning: This review discusses the complete novel, including its ending.

Content note: Domestic abuse, cruelty to children and animals, and death.

IN THIS REVIEW
Wind-bent heather and a dry-stone wall cross a storm-dark Yorkshire moor toward a distant farmhouse.

THE BOOK

Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë, Penguin Classics book cover.

Wuthering Heights
Emily Brontë

First publication
1847

Form · Novel

Edition & cover details
Read the primary text free
Find an edition

Lockwood’s introduction to Wuthering Heights is an excellent corrective to any expectation of gracious country-house romance. The hospitality is hostile, the family relationships are baffling, and even the dogs have objections to his presence.

Emily Brontë begins with a visitor who misunderstands what he sees, then hands much of the story to a woman whose familiarity does not make her innocent of its events. Before Catherine and Heathcliff become legendary lovers, they are people encountered through other people’s telling.

I love the ferocity of this novel’s atmosphere. The wind, the windows and the distances between the houses feel capable of entering the body. Yet its most disturbing achievement is the patience with which it follows a powerful attachment into the lives of people who never consented to serve it.

Who is telling the story?

Nelly Dean has information Lockwood lacks, but she also has preferences, resentments and a role in the history she recounts. Her decisions about what to disclose or withhold affect the people she describes. Reading her as a perfectly transparent window removes much of the novel’s interest.

The layered narration gives intimacy an uncomfortable distance. We hear speeches preserved through memory and relayed to a stranger. Even the famous declarations reach us through an arrangement that encourages belief while making complete certainty unavailable.

Heathcliff’s childhood explains a great deal without settling what we should think of the adult. Hindley’s degradation of him turns a family home into an education in humiliation. Catherine is his companion within that world, and their attachment develops with the force of a private allegiance.

When Catherine imagines marrying Edgar while maintaining her bond with Heathcliff, she assumes that desire can outwit the arrangements of property and status. Heathcliff overhears only part of her confession and leaves. The broken communication is crucial, but the damage is larger than a sentence heard incorrectly: she is trying to divide a life that will not remain divided.

The people passion makes expendable

Heathcliff’s return is thrilling because Brontë gives him presence before giving us any reassurance about its use. Wealth makes possible the retaliation childhood denied him. The people closest to his enemies become instruments through which he can continue the original quarrel.

Isabella’s marriage exposes the consequences most directly. Her attraction is met with deliberate cruelty. The novel gives her enough room to discover that the figure she desired has no obligation, in his own understanding, to resemble the man she imagined.

Catherine’s death intensifies rather than concludes the attachment. Heathcliff’s grief is immense, and Brontë can make that grief almost unbearable to witness. But his anguish coexists with the calculated treatment of Hareton, his own son Linton and the younger Catherine.

That coexistence is why I resist turning him into an ideal lover. The novel’s emotional power does not depend on approving his conduct. His capacity to suffer cannot cancel the suffering he chooses to arrange.

The manipulation of the younger generation is especially ugly because it borrows the forms of family duty. Marriage, guardianship and inheritance give resentment practical tools. Revenge can enter the next room, determine who learns to read, and decide which young person may leave the house.

An ending the young must make

Hareton’s deprivation repeats parts of Heathcliff’s own upbringing. The younger Catherine initially answers his roughness with contempt, and the book refuses to make either of them instantly generous. Their change develops through embarrassment, injury and the difficult business of looking again.

Their shared reading matters because education has been used as a weapon. Catherine’s willingness to help him becomes an alteration in the household’s habits. Somebody begins to offer what another person has deliberately withheld.

I find this tentative companionship more moving because the older passion remains so overwhelming. Emily Brontë does not give the young its grandeur, but she allows them the possibility of daily life together. Their future need not be organised around somebody else’s grievance.

The closing quiet does not fully domesticate the book. Ghostly suggestions and Lockwood’s final impressions leave room for the dead to remain unsettling. Nor does the prospect of marriage restore those already harmed.

What it offers is smaller and more difficult to romanticise: two people who may learn to inhabit a house without making the other person pay for everything that happened before. After the violence of these rooms, that possibility feels substantial.

Primary text: Wuthering Heights · Cover shown: ISBN 9780141439556

READ NEXT

Leave a Comment