Jane’s love for Rochester is never in doubt. What gives the novel its force is the moment she decides that loving him cannot settle every question about her life.
A review of Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë
By H.R. Zimmerer
Spoiler warning: This review discusses the complete novel, including its ending.
Content note: Childhood abuse, coercion and confinement.
IN THIS REVIEW

THE BOOK

Jane Eyre
Charlotte Brontë
First publication
1847
Form · Novel
Edition & cover details
Read the primary text free
Find an edition
The most difficult departure in Jane Eyre happens after Jane has found almost everything she wanted. At Thornfield she has work, companionship and a man whose attention makes her feel vividly present. Leaving means giving up a possible home before she knows where another one might be.
That is why I find the novel’s romance so compelling. Charlotte Brontë allows desire to become urgent without making it a sufficient argument. Jane wants Rochester. She also understands that he is asking her to live inside an arrangement whose terms he has concealed.
The interrupted wedding is a spectacular revelation, but the quieter struggle afterwards matters more to me: a woman alone with somebody she loves, refusing the explanation that would let her stay.
A child nobody wishes to hear
Jane’s insistence on being heard begins well before Rochester enters the book. At Gateshead, her dependence becomes an excuse for treating her account of her own life as insolence. The red-room punishment is frightening because the adults have already decided whose version of events deserves belief.
Lowood changes the institution without immediately changing that imbalance. Brocklehurst’s public righteousness permits private cruelty; the girls’ hunger and cold expose the comfortable distance between his principles and their application. Helen Burns offers Jane a different understanding of endurance, while Miss Temple supplies the practical kindness that makes an adult’s goodness believable.
I appreciate the tension between those influences. Jane can admire Helen without becoming her. The novel gives moral seriousness to a child whose anger is frequently inconvenient, and it lets education become a means of earning a living as well as a lesson in obedience.
By the time she advertises for a position, Jane has acquired a skill with which to enter the world. Her arrival at Thornfield carries the excitement of employment and new experience alongside the promise of Gothic mystery.
Desire does not excuse concealment
Rochester’s attraction rests partly on conversation. He finds somebody who will answer him, and Jane discovers the pleasure of speaking without continually reducing herself to the dimensions of her position. Their exchanges have an intelligence that makes the later deception more painful.
His behaviour also deserves scrutiny before the wedding. The masquerade as a fortune-teller and the performance around Blanche Ingram give him information and provoke Jane’s jealousy while keeping his own intentions protected. His emotional exposure is repeatedly arranged on terms he controls.
Bertha Mason’s existence makes that pattern impossible to dismiss. Rochester has suffered, but his suffering does not entitle him to decide what Jane may know before she marries him. His account is persuasive because he is persuasive. Brontë makes us feel the attraction of accepting it.
The book’s treatment of Bertha remains its deepest difficulty for me. Jane receives an extraordinarily rich inner life; Bertha is confined within violent appearances and other people’s accounts. The racialised language surrounding her makes the imbalance harsher. I cannot read the ending as uncomplicated liberation while forgetting the woman whose death clears its way.
Jane’s refusal still has tremendous force. She leaves without the reassurance that obedience to her convictions will be rewarded. The deprivation that follows gives her decision a material cost.
Returning with a life of her own
St John Rivers offers a different kind of surrender. His proposal has the authority of religious duty behind it, but he wants a wife fitted to his mission, with Jane’s emotional life treated as something to overcome. The novel asks her to resist a cold claim upon her as firmly as she resisted a passionate one.
Her inheritance changes what returning can mean. She has money, family and the ability to leave again. I also value her decision to divide the fortune with the Rivers siblings: belonging becomes something she actively makes, rather than a favour she must earn by being useful.
The reunion at Ferndean is tender, though Rochester’s injuries and Bertha’s death make its arrangement troubling as well as satisfying. The novel works hard to bring Jane and Rochester together under altered conditions. Those conditions invite questions; they do not erase the pleasure of hearing Jane narrate the choice herself.
Jane Eyre earns its emotional intensity through a heroine who can want deeply and still judge. The words that stay with me are less a declaration of devotion than the conviction behind her departure. Jane believes her life must remain answerable to her, even when the person asking her to surrender it is the person she most desires.
Primary text: Jane Eyre · Cover shown: ISBN 9780141441146
READ NEXT
- Mansfield Park: What Fanny Price Refuses — another difficult refusal under pressure.
- Persuasion: The Years Between Them — a return shaped by time and altered judgement.
