Posted on: April 9, 2025 Posted by: H.R. Zimmerer Comments: 0

Charlotte Brontë’s first completed novel gives a man the story of earning independence. His account becomes more interesting when we ask what kinds of authority he still wants to keep.

A review of The Professor by Charlotte Brontë

By H.R. Zimmerer

Spoiler warning: This review discusses the complete novel, including its ending.

Content note: Workplace humiliation and controlling relationships.

IN THIS REVIEW
Wooden school desks and papers face an open doorway to a cobbled, ivy-framed courtyard.

THE BOOK

The Professor by Charlotte Brontë, Penguin Classics book cover.

The Professor
Charlotte Brontë

First publication
1857 · published posthumously

Form · Novel

Edition & cover details
Read the primary text free
Find an edition

William Crimsworth is determined to earn his way. His refusal to remain dependent gives The Professor an apparently straightforward direction: escape humiliation, acquire useful work, and make a life through ability.

Charlotte Brontë complicates that direction by giving William considerable confidence in his own judgement. He can recognise condescension when he receives it. Recognising the advantages he seeks over other people is less convenient.

This is the first novel Charlotte completed, though it was published after her death. I find it most interesting beside the richer ambiguities of Villette. The Belgian setting and the work of teaching are already present, along with an absorbing tension between independence and the desire to supervise someone else’s.

The dignity of earning a living

William’s work for his brother Edward makes family connection a source of humiliation rather than safety. His education does not protect him from being diminished at the mill. The decision to leave carries a reasonable hunger to be judged by what he can do.

In Belgium, teaching offers a new arrangement. Knowledge can be exchanged for wages; competence can produce respect. Charlotte pays attention to the satisfaction of becoming useful in a position one has chosen.

I like that practical energy. Employment is allowed to interest the narrative on its own terms. Lessons, languages and professional reputation matter because they govern the possibilities available at the end of a working day.

William’s account nevertheless carries prejudgements about nationality, religion and appearance that make his certainty uncomfortable. The people around him are often ranked before they have been granted much opportunity to surprise him.

Watching from the master’s desk

Mlle Reuter’s attention initially flatters him. When he discovers that her intentions differ from what he had imagined, the disappointment sharpens his sense of being manipulated. His observations become a means of recovering superiority.

Charlotte makes the school an institution in which people watch one another for signs of preference, usefulness and weakness. William dislikes becoming the object of calculation, yet he is an energetic calculator himself.

Frances Henri offers a different attachment. Her limited resources and determination to work give her an ambition the novel treats seriously. She does not simply wait to become the reward at the end of William’s professional improvement.

The trouble, for me, lies in the terms under which her value is repeatedly recognised. Her diligence and responsiveness make her attractive to a narrator who enjoys the position of instructor. The relationship can appear most harmonious when his authority is least disturbed.

That tension produces more interest than a flawless courtship would. William has good reasons to value self-reliance. He also has a capacity to make his approval the measure by which another person’s independence is admitted.

Frances wants work of her own

Frances’s desire to continue working after marriage gives the ending welcome substance. Her professional plans cannot be folded entirely into William’s achievement. The school becomes a shared enterprise, with success arising from abilities both bring to it.

The novel is attentive to the material advantages of that success. Financial security, travel and the possibility of choosing where to live belong to its understanding of happiness. Love does not make the ledger irrelevant.

I wish Frances were allowed more room outside William’s assessments. The narrative gives her determination, but we receive it through a voice unusually ready to decide what people mean. Later Charlotte would make the management of disclosure itself a far more troubling subject.

The comparatively orderly ending can also feel too efficient. Work and marriage align with a neatness that leaves some of the earlier contests over power insufficiently tested.

For those reasons, I would begin with Jane Eyre or Villette before this novel. The Professor rewards a reader interested in the development of Charlotte’s concerns: paid work, the humiliation of dependence, the pleasure of being recognised and the danger of mistaking recognition for ownership. Frances’s insistence on a useful life gives that development its most persuasive direction.

Primary text: The Professor · Cover shown: ISBN 9780140433111

READ NEXT

Leave a Comment