Caroline Helstone and Shirley Keeldar have very different resources. Their friendship exposes how much a young woman’s future depends on the work, money and company available to her.
A review of Shirley by Charlotte Brontë
By H.R. Zimmerer
Spoiler warning: This review discusses the complete novel, including its ending.
Content note: Industrial violence and serious illness.
IN THIS REVIEW

THE BOOK

Shirley
Charlotte Brontë
First publication
1849
Form · Novel
Edition & cover details
Read the primary text free
Find an edition
For much of Shirley, Caroline Helstone has painfully little to do. She is young, intelligent and capable of affection, but her days offer few ways to turn those abilities into a life she can shape.
Charlotte Brontë makes the waiting uncomfortable. The novel is set amid industrial conflict, and events outside the house can become loud and dangerous. Inside it, a woman’s lack of occupation creates another kind of pressure.
The arrival of Shirley Keeldar gives that pressure somebody to push against. Shirley has money, property and a freedom of manner Caroline cannot easily claim. Their friendship is the part of this sprawling, uneven novel I find most rewarding.
When waiting becomes an occupation
Caroline’s attachment to Robert Moore makes the limits of her position personal. His mill is in difficulty, and his calculations about marriage cannot be separated from the financial demands of keeping it running.
She has feeling to offer; he believes he needs capital. Charlotte allows that disparity to hurt without pretending that every problem can be solved through a sincere conversation.
Caroline’s consideration of work is equally revealing. Becoming a governess appears as one of the few respectable possibilities, and even that possibility meets resistance. Concern for her can become a reason to leave the arrangement that makes her miserable intact.
The older unmarried women around her offer varied glimpses of what a life outside marriage might become. Charlotte’s treatment is not always generous, but Caroline’s need for purpose prevents the question from remaining a convenient joke about spinsters.
Friendship beside the mill
Shirley enters with the privileges of an heiress and the confidence to inhabit them. People respond to her manner because her resources give it consequence. Behaviours that might be condemned in Caroline can become entertaining or impressive in a wealthy young woman.
I enjoy Shirley’s appetite for argument and her unwillingness to behave as though intelligence must apologise for itself. More valuable still is her capacity to become Caroline’s friend within a plot that could easily have reduced them to rivals.
Their companionship creates room for conversation beyond the question of which man will choose them. They have distinct temperaments, and the difference allows each to see possibilities the other has not quite been able to imagine alone.
The industrial plot makes the distribution of power more public. Robert’s machinery threatens the livelihoods of workers already under pressure, while his own survival as a manufacturer depends on economic circumstances he cannot wholly control. The attack on the mill turns those pressures into bodily danger.
Here I find the novel’s reach larger than its consistency. It can perceive the desperation surrounding industrial change, yet its workers do not always receive the inward attention given to its central household figures. The compassionate encounters are persuasive; the settlement of the conflict feels less adequate to the scale of what has been exposed.
What the marriages resolve
Caroline’s serious illness brings neglected emotional needs into the open. Mrs Pryor’s disclosure that she is her mother supplies care and a history Caroline has been denied. The revelation is melodramatic, but the bodily need behind it has been carefully prepared.
Shirley’s relationship with Louis Moore introduces a further complication. The woman whose wealth gives her public independence is drawn toward a man whose private manner can become commanding. Charlotte plainly finds energy in that struggle over authority.
I am less satisfied when the marriage plot seems ready to contain Shirley by celebrating the man capable of mastering her. Her earlier freedom is one of the novel’s pleasures, so the prospect of its domestication cannot pass without resistance.
The double marriage offers personal futures more decisively than it answers the larger questions about useful work and industrial society. Even the closing glimpse of the altered landscape allows progress to carry a sense of loss.
Shirley is not the Charlotte novel I would choose for the tightest construction. Its digressions, clerical caricatures and changes in emphasis can be cumbersome. But Caroline’s empty days and the company that interrupts them have a truth I value. The book understands that being provided for does not necessarily give a person enough to live for.
Primary text: Shirley · Cover shown: ISBN 9780141439860
