Posted on: June 19, 2025 Posted by: H.R. Zimmerer Comments: 0

Pip’s rise teaches him to feel ashamed of the person who has loved him best. Dickens makes that shame the difficult centre of a story usually remembered for its mysteries.

A review of Great Expectations by Charles Dickens

By H.R. Zimmerer

Spoiler warning: This review discusses the complete novel, including its ending.

Content note: Childhood abuse, domestic violence and death.

IN THIS REVIEW
An old iron gate opens through a rain-dark garden with faded roses and mist beyond.

THE BOOK

Great Expectations by Charles Dickens, Penguin Classics book cover.

Great Expectations
Charles Dickens

First publication
1860–1861 · serial; 1861 · volume

Form · Novel

Edition & cover details
Read the primary text free
Find an edition

Pip is ashamed of Joe long before he has achieved anything that might justify feeling superior to him. That is the wound Great Expectations keeps pressing. A child is taught to despise the circumstances of his own affection, then mistakes the opportunity to escape them for evidence that he deserves something better.

Dickens gives that education an unforgettable setting. The marshes are cold and frightening; Satis House is crowded with the remains of an event nobody is permitted to finish. Pip enters both places without understanding the adult histories waiting there.

I find his narration compelling because the older voice can recognise a cruelty the younger self is still busy explaining. The distance between the two allows shame to become an experience we watch being acquired.

Learning to look down

Estella’s contempt gives Pip a new view of his hands, his boots and the forge. Things that belonged to his ordinary life become evidence against him. His attraction is inseparable from the wish to stop being the person she can dismiss.

Miss Havisham encourages that confusion. Her betrayal has become a household regime, and Estella is being educated to carry it outward. The stopped clocks and ruined feast are extraordinary Gothic inventions, but their real horror lies in the decision to make another person live inside an old injury.

Joe’s gentleness cannot compete with the glamour Pip assigns to Satis House. Dickens makes the imbalance painful by giving Joe a dignity Pip is not ready to value. His awkwardness in unfamiliar company does not indicate a lack of feeling or judgement.

The London visit is especially uncomfortable. Pip is embarrassed by Joe’s manner and then ashamed of the embarrassment, without yet possessing the courage to behave better. I appreciate how little protection Dickens gives him. A narrator can know he was wrong and still be required to tell us what the wrong looked like.

The benefactor he did not want

Magwitch’s return destroys the flattering story Pip has made of his expectations. The money has come from a transported convict, not from Miss Havisham’s supposed design to prepare him for Estella.

The reversal joins the book’s two great settings. The frightening man on the marshes has been working toward the life Pip believed would lift him above that encounter. His gentility depends on somebody the social world has taught him to recoil from.

Magwitch’s devotion is moving without being free of possessiveness. Pip’s success has become a means by which he can answer humiliation. He wants to make a gentleman and see the result. Dickens allows generosity to contain a claim upon the recipient.

Pip’s care for him nevertheless changes the moral direction of the novel. The attempted escape and the attention after its failure place loyalty where disgust had been. He begins doing useful things for a person whose association can bring him no social advantage.

Estella’s history creates a related difficulty. She has repeatedly described the limits of what she can offer, but Pip keeps treating desire as a reason to expect a different answer. Her later suffering in marriage is appalling; it should not be necessary to imagine that suffering as a lesson designed to make her suitable for him.

The work after disillusionment

Miss Havisham’s recognition of the damage she has done gives her regret a terrible urgency. Pip’s attempt to save her from the fire is bodily and immediate, quite unlike the distant fantasies through which he has previously imagined helping or being rewarded.

Joe’s care during Pip’s illness brings the novel back to the love he has neglected. The payment of his debts is almost unbearable in its generosity. Pip has wanted refinement; Joe has quietly undertaken responsibility.

Dickens does not return him to the forge as though experience can be undone. Biddy has married Joe, and the future Pip half imagines claiming is already somebody else’s. He has to work and enter a life without the promised shape he once assigned to it.

The revised, commonly printed ending with Estella remains beautifully uneasy. It offers the possibility of continued companionship through language that has invited disagreement ever since. I would not force certainty upon it. The earlier ending is starker, and knowing both makes the desire for consolation more visible.

For me, the novel’s deepest satisfaction has already occurred. Pip has learned to distinguish the appearance of distinction from the conduct of someone worth loving. Dickens earns that knowledge by making him live through the harm done while he preferred the appearance.

Primary text: Great Expectations · Cover shown: ISBN 9780141439563

READ NEXT

Leave a Comment