The famous sacrifice at the end depends on a quieter question running through the novel: can suffering be acknowledged without turning another person into its payment?
A review of A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens
By H.R. Zimmerer
Spoiler warning: This review discusses the complete novel, including its ending.
Content note: Imprisonment, sexual violence in an account of the past, and execution.
IN THIS REVIEW

THE BOOK

A Tale of Two Cities
Charles Dickens
First publication
1859
Form · Novel
Edition & cover details
Read the primary text free
Find an edition
Dr Manette is released from prison before he is free of it. His return to shoemaking shows captivity continuing inside a room where nobody is physically preventing him from leaving.
That persistence gives A Tale of Two Cities a human scale beneath its enormous historical movement. Dickens is writing about revolution, inherited cruelty and public violence. He keeps returning to what those forces do to a person trying to sit safely among people he loves.
The novel’s plotting is unusually concentrated for Dickens. Names, resemblances and apparently minor encounters acquire later force. I admire the construction, even where the machinery becomes visible.
A past that will not stay past
Lucie’s care helps her father rebuild ordinary life, but the possibility of relapse never becomes merely decorative suspense. Happiness cannot guarantee that the mind will remain in the present. Dickens allows recovery to require attention beyond the first joyful reunion.
Charles Darnay’s rejection of his aristocratic family’s conduct is important precisely because he cannot abolish the history attached to its name. His wish to live differently is sincere. Other people’s knowledge of what his family has done is also substantial.
The Marquis’s treatment of the people beneath him establishes an order in which rank repeatedly protects cruelty from consequence. The revolution does not arise because its participants have spontaneously developed a taste for malice. Dickens supplies reasons for their fury.
He is equally determined to show what happens when an explanation becomes an unlimited permission. The same desire to make a class answer for individual suffering can turn a person into a name on a list, with no adequate distinction between guilt and relation.
When memory becomes a sentence
Madame Defarge embodies this danger with frightening discipline. Her family’s suffering gives her commitment a history the novel wants us to understand. The knitting turns the preservation of that history into a record capable of directing future violence.
I find her most disturbing when the claim for justice extends to Lucie and her child. A wrong that deserves acknowledgement becomes the warrant for erasing anybody connected to the wrongdoers. The future is required to inherit a sentence.
Dr Manette’s prison document produces a cruel inversion of his hopes. The record of what he witnessed becomes evidence against the man his daughter loves. His earlier self cannot know the family his later testimony will help endanger.
That convergence is brilliantly arranged, though the coincidences sometimes feel too exact for the breadth of the historical setting. Dickens compresses a great public catastrophe into an intimate mechanism. The emotional precision is the benefit; a narrowed sense of historical complexity is part of the cost.
Lucie’s role carries a related limitation. She is central to the attachments that motivate the plot, but she receives less contradictory inner life than the men whose lives she changes. I value the care she gives while wishing she were allowed a fuller range of desires and judgements beyond giving it.
What Carton can still choose
Sydney Carton’s resemblance to Darnay begins as a practical legal advantage and becomes the means of his final act. Dickens prepares the substitution through a man who considers his own possibilities largely exhausted.
His love for Lucie matters, but the act is moving because he expects no romantic return. The life preserved will continue without his participation in its ordinary happiness. His choice takes the future seriously even though he will not inhabit it.
I am wary of making his death the simple proof that a disappointed life has acquired worth. The novel’s Christian language of resurrection gives his decision a larger frame, yet the human cost remains severe. His lost possibilities are part of what makes the scene hurt.
The encounter with the young seamstress prevents the close from belonging only to the grand gesture. Carton has somebody beside him who is afraid. His attention narrows to what comfort he can offer her during the time that remains.
That tenderness is the ending I most value. Against a public system that treats people as exchangeable representatives, Dickens gives us two particular people capable of seeing each other. The sacrifice is immense; the hand held on the way to it makes its meaning intimate.
Primary text: A Tale of Two Cities · Cover shown: ISBN 9780141439600
