David tells the story of becoming the hero of his own life. The people at its edges reveal how much a successful account can owe to lives that do not resolve so neatly.
A review of David Copperfield by Charles Dickens
By H.R. Zimmerer
Spoiler warning: This review discusses the complete novel, including its ending.
Content note: Child abuse, exploitation and bereavement.

THE BOOK

David Copperfield
Charles Dickens
First publication
1849–1850 · serial; 1850 · volume
Form · Novel
Edition & cover details
Read the primary text free
Find an edition
David Copperfield begins by considering whether he will prove the hero of his own life. It is a wonderfully inviting question, and also a useful warning about the authority a person acquires when telling the story after the outcome is known.
I find the novel richest when David’s success does not quite contain everybody who helped make it possible. Its households are crowded with unforgettable people, some generous, some grotesque, some able to be both within a single scene.
Dickens can make companionship a source of enormous pleasure here. That pleasure gives the losses weight. A world made only to demonstrate suffering would not be nearly so difficult to leave.
A child made small
The Murdstones change David’s home by giving intimidation the name of firmness. His mother’s affection becomes something to correct; his fear becomes evidence that he requires more discipline. The household contracts around the judgement of people certain they know what is best.
The warehouse passages are especially powerful because shame accompanies the work. David is distressed by what has happened to him and by the thought of being seen there. The narrator remembers deprivation as an injury to his sense of who he might become.
Betsey Trotwood’s protection therefore matters as a practical intervention. She can be eccentric and formidable while still doing the essential thing: she listens, decides and makes room. Her house permits a future to resume.
Mr Dick adds another kind of generosity. The novel’s treatment of his vulnerability is not free of comedy at his expense, but it repeatedly gives his attention and feeling a usefulness more confident people fail to achieve. Competence does not arrive in only one approved social form.
The people charm can injure
Steerforth’s attraction is central to David’s education. David sees assurance, beauty and an ease he longs to share. The warning signs do not remain wholly hidden; affection supplies him with reasons to minimise them.
Little Em’ly’s fate exposes what that charm can cost outside the friendship that first made it appealing. Her hopes of rising in the world become available to a man whose advantages protect him from needing to take the same risks.
Mr Peggotty’s search gives devotion an extraordinary physical scale. He continues across distances because she remains somebody he loves when the surrounding world is ready to reduce her to a cautionary account.
Ham’s death while attempting a rescue during the storm brings the novel’s moral and narrative arrangements together with devastating force. Dickens is magnificent at making weather bodily frightening. The discovery of Steerforth among its victims gives the scene a symbolic completeness that I admire and also feel being imposed.
Em’ly’s new life abroad offers a future, but it also moves her away from the English world in which David’s success will be secured. The novel’s sympathy reaches her more fully than its domestic ending can accommodate her.
Who fits the happy ending?
Dora’s marriage to David exposes the difference between loving an enchanting person and expecting that person to perform an imagined domestic role. David has helped create the expectations that later disappoint him.
I find the tenderness of their attachment more affecting than the assumption that maturity requires Dora to be superseded. Her death is moving, yet the structure risks making a young wife’s inadequacy the preparation for a wiser marriage.
Agnes offers steadiness and understanding, but the ideal can leave her carrying an unfair amount of emotional work. I want more room for the difficulty of being endlessly perceptive on somebody else’s behalf.
The Micawbers provide a wonderfully unruly counterweight to domestic perfection. Their debts and grandiloquence can be exasperating, but the language gives them irrepressible life. Mr Micawber’s part in exposing Uriah Heep turns a familiar comic performance toward effective action.
The conclusion is generous, busy and sometimes too ready to distribute everyone to an appropriate destination. I still love the novel’s abundance. David’s life feels inhabited because Dickens has created people who exceed their immediate usefulness to it.
The question from the opening remains productive at the close. Becoming the hero of your own account does not necessarily make you its most perceptive reader. David’s gratitude, blindness and retrospective affection keep that possibility open.
Primary text: David Copperfield · Cover shown: ISBN 9780140439441
