The ghosts make Scrooge feel. The morning after gives those feelings their test: what he does with his money, his time and the people he has kept at a distance.
A review of A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens
By H.R. Zimmerer
Spoiler warning: This review discusses the complete novella, including its ending.
Content note: Poverty, bereavement and the threatened death of a child.
IN THIS REVIEW

THE BOOK

A Christmas Carol
Charles Dickens
First publication
1843
Form · Novella
Edition & cover details
Read the primary text free
Find an edition
Scrooge wakes on Christmas morning with an advantage most people do not receive after recognising their mistakes: he still has time to act upon what he has seen.
I love the exuberance of that waking. His delight is almost ridiculous, which makes it more convincing. A man who has spent years policing every unnecessary pleasure discovers that joy is going to make him look foolish and accepts the embarrassment.
But the ending of A Christmas Carol matters beyond the change in his mood. Dickens takes a ghost story through memory, hospitality and terror before arriving at the practical business of an altered life.
A life that has grown smaller
Scrooge’s solitude is established through habits. The cold room, the grudging attention to Bob Cratchit’s fire and the refusal of Fred’s invitation reveal a person whose resources are continually directed toward keeping other people’s claims away.
Marley’s arrival makes that strategy suddenly visible as a burden. The chain turns a lifetime’s transactions into something its owner must carry. It is an extraordinarily efficient supernatural image because the materials belong to the life Marley actually chose.
The Ghost of Christmas Past complicates Scrooge’s history without treating it as an acquittal. The lonely child, his sister Fan and the affectionate energy of Fezziwig’s gathering show capacities that have been neglected rather than entirely absent.
Belle’s departure gives his narrowing life a personal consequence. Money has become the governing attachment around which other commitments must arrange themselves. The memory hurts because Scrooge can recognise the choice while being unable to revise the scene.
A place set for somebody else
Fezziwig’s value lies partly in the disproportion between the expenditure and what it makes possible. His celebration offers rest, welcome and the temporary pleasure of being more than a worker completing a task. Scrooge understands that kind of authority because he has experienced its good use.
The Cratchits’ Christmas is more complicated than an attractive picture of modest means. Their affection is real; so are the constraints under which they provide the meal. I would not use their happiness as evidence that their poverty does not matter.
Bob’s willingness to toast his employer is generous almost to the point of pain. Mrs Cratchit supplies a necessary objection. Dickens permits the household to contain gratitude, irritation and love together, which saves it from becoming only an illustration of cheerful deprivation.
Tiny Tim is an openly sentimental figure, and the emotional method will not work equally for every reader. Yet the question Scrooge asks about his survival has a precise force. A child he has never troubled to know is suddenly someone whose future concerns him.
The children named Ignorance and Want widen the encounter beyond one deserving family. The apparition is blunt, but its placement matters: Scrooge cannot solve what he has seen solely by becoming fond of Bob’s son.
The morning is where it counts
The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come offers no flattering account of the mark Scrooge will leave. His death produces convenience, calculation and the dispersal of his possessions. The possibility of a life that ends without being mourned is terrifying because it measures the relationships he has actually made.
The grave is the point at which fear and hope become inseparable. He wants the future to be alterable. The story’s Christian understanding of repentance makes room for that desire without suggesting that the past can cease to have happened.
His changed conduct begins immediately. He sends food, contributes to charity, joins Fred’s gathering and raises Bob’s salary. The sequence gives generosity several forms, from the material to the social. A cheerful feeling is not required to carry the entire burden of his reform.
The speed is the great convenience of the fable. Lasting change ordinarily involves repeated choices after the first intensity has faded, and the narrator’s assurance does some necessary work at the close.
I accept that assurance because the morning has shown the direction of his effort so clearly. Scrooge risks welcome, spends money and attends to somebody else’s need. The possibility that moves me is the permission to begin doing those things while the people who need them are still here.
Primary text: A Christmas Carol · Cover shown: ISBN 9780141324524
