Posted on: October 13, 2026 Posted by: H.R. Zimmerer Comments: 0
Official Out Of Ashes album cover: a crumpled black form and geometric white emblem on an off-white background, with red and black lettering.

On Out Of Ashes, Dead By Sunrise give Chester Bennington room for a different kind of expression. The most rewarding moments come when the songs let his melodic singing carry as much weight as the force.

IN THIS ARTICLE

Chester Bennington’s voice is so closely associated with Linkin Park that hearing it in another band changes your attention almost immediately. The grain is familiar. The musical conversation around it has changed. On Out Of Ashes, that difference makes room for a singer whose range of feeling can be easy to underestimate when the discussion stops at how powerfully he could scream.

Dead By Sunrise’s album has its share of hard, direct songs. It also makes time for romance, disappointment, and sustained melody. Those changes of mood are a substantial part of its appeal. The record gives you several ways to recognise Bennington.

Dead By Sunrise Out Of Ashes review graphic by H.R. Zimmerer: engraved charred woodland and a warm dawn glow, framed by indigo flowers, plum peonies and ferns around a black title panel.

THE RECORD

Artist: Dead By Sunrise
Album: Out Of Ashes
Original U.S. release: October 13, 2009

Review edition: 13-track streaming edition, including “Morning After”
Running time: Approximately 47 minutes
Label: Warner Records
Producer: Howard Benson

Listen on Apple Music · Listen on Spotify

The original U.S. album contained 12 songs. This review’s listening links use the 13-track streaming edition.

Songs with a different destination

Speaking about the project in 2009, Bennington explained that he had written material whose character did not suit Linkin Park. The contemporary interview coverage makes the intention clear: these songs needed somewhere else to develop. That is a more useful starting point than treating the album as a collection of material left over from his better-known band.

The absence of Linkin Park’s familiar exchange between singing and rap changes the dramatic shape. Bennington carries the vocal narrative for longer stretches. Songs can remain inside a melodic thought, or move from a restrained verse towards a broad chorus, without handing the perspective to another voice. The result is a more continuous kind of exposure.

A band around a familiar voice

Guitarists Ryan Shuck and Amir Derakh are central to this setting, with the group’s electronic textures sitting alongside the guitars. The recording credits also identify Brandon Belsky on bass and programming, Elias Andra on drums, and Anthony Valcic on synthesizer and programming. There is a band constructing the space around the vocal, even when Bennington’s presence dominates your attention.

Howard Benson’s production gives the songs an accessible, polished hard-rock frame. That suits the immediate hooks and broad melodic lines. It also means the record’s individuality often arrives through a vocal inflection or a particular turn towards tenderness, rather than through an unfamiliar arrangement.

The performances worth staying for

“Fire”

The opening song makes a good case for the album’s melodic ambitions. Its movement towards a larger chorus gives Bennington room to sound expansive, with an emotional openness that matters as much as the volume. As an introduction, it establishes that this record’s darkness will have more than one colour.

“Crawl Back In”

The compact shape and forceful hook make this an effective early statement. There is little wasted space between its unease and its release. Bennington’s delivery gives the struggle urgency, while the song stays direct enough to work as an invitation into the rest of the album.

“Let Down”

This is where the record’s willingness to stay with a melody becomes especially rewarding. Disappointment is carried through the phrasing and the gradual expansion of the song. The appeal is in hearing a recognisable voice take time with a feeling, allowing the vulnerability to remain audible as the arrangement grows.

“Give Me Your Name” and “In the Darkness”

The more intimate songs are essential to the portrait the album offers. Their attention to desire and attachment gives Bennington a different emotional register to inhabit. “In the Darkness,” in particular, makes the later part of the original sequence worth reaching. A listener who comes only for the aggressive tracks misses a substantial part of what distinguishes this band.

“Walking in Circles”

The song’s central idea gives the late-album stretch an uneasy persistence. Its sense of repetition and entrapment fits the record’s recurring concern with states that are difficult to escape. Bennington’s ability to make a melodic line feel pressured keeps that concern immediate, even within a familiar rock structure.

Where the frame becomes familiar

Some of the heavier songs share enough of the period’s radio-rock vocabulary that they can feel less individual than the singing inside them. The brisk aggression of “My Suffering” and “Condemned” supplies useful contrast, but the album becomes more distinctive when it lets the emotional temperature shift further.

There are also passages where the lyrical language is broad enough to leave most of the work to the vocal. That is a real limitation, and Bennington is unusually capable of carrying it. A less expressive singer would expose the difference between an immediately recognisable feeling and a particularly revealing piece of writing.

Let the record have its own moment

Revisiting Bennington’s work after his death inevitably changes the listening context. The temptation is to treat every dark song as an explanation of what happened later. That approach would make this album much smaller. There is affection here, and pleasure in melody, and a musician choosing what another group of collaborators could help him do.

After Linkin Park’s Unshatter soundtrack, Out Of Ashes makes a rewarding change of perspective. The live album places a catalogue in the hands of the band’s present. This record takes us to a different part of Bennington’s working life. “Let Down” and “In the Darkness” are reason enough to spend time there.

Start with: “Fire,” “Crawl Back In,” “Let Down,” and “In the Darkness.” On the linked streaming edition, “Morning After” follows the original album sequence.

Listen to the album

Hear the complete Out Of Ashes on Spotify or Apple Music. The official “Crawl Back In” video is embedded below.

youtube placeholder image

Watch “Crawl Back In” on the artist’s official YouTube channel.

Sources and further reading


Explore more music reviews from The Indigo Chronicle

READ NEXT

Linkin Park’s Unshatter: The Joy of Hearing These Songs Live Again

The band’s past and present meet in the São Paulo live soundtrack.

Linkin Park’s “Lost”

The recovered recording, Bennington’s performance, and the experience of hearing that voice again.